2025 was one of the best years the South Haven, Bangor and Covert reporting area has had in some time. The Southwestern Michigan Association of REALTORS counted 400 residential sales there for the full year, up 7% from 2024. The average sale price rose 18% to $506,717 and total dollar volume rose 27%. Nine months into 2026, the same area is behind. Sales through September 2026 totaled 280 against 300 at the same point in 2025, and the year-to-date average price is down 9% to $474,900.
Two other numbers held steady. The median price barely shifted, and inventory sits about where it was a year ago. For anyone weighing a purchase this winter, the calendar matters more than the trend line, because last year the supply of listings dropped sharply in December.
The average fell three times as far as the median
Through September 2026, the area's median sale price was $365,450, down 3% from $376,275 over the same months of 2025. In the same period the average sale price fell 9%, from $519,319 to $474,900.
That gap tells you where the change happened. The median is the price in the middle of the line, so a few very expensive sales barely move it. The average adds up every dollar and divides, so a single Lake Michigan frontage sale can lift it, and its absence shows up quickly. When the average drops by roughly $44,000 and the median by roughly $11,000, the pattern points to fewer sales at the high end. Homes in the middle are selling at about the same prices as last year.
Dollar volume points the same way. Residential sales in the area totaled about $133 million through September 2026, against about $155.8 million a year earlier, a 15% drop. Twenty fewer sales cannot explain a $22.8 million gap at a median near $365,000. The missing dollars sit mostly at the top.
September 2026 showed this most clearly. The area recorded 37 sales that month against 61 in September 2025, and dollar volume fell by half, from about $35.5 million to about $17.8 million. The median that month was $365,900, down from $399,900. One month is a small sample, and August 2026 pointed the other way, with 49 sales against 40 a year earlier and a $375,000 median that was nearly flat. The year-to-date figures are steadier, and they tell the same story about the high end.
One caveat applies to all of this. SWMAR reports South Haven, Bangor and Covert together as one area. The combined area figures do not separate Lake Michigan waterfront sales from inland homes. They show where the dollars went, but they do not label which homes those dollars bought.
Slower sales without a pile-up of listings
A slowdown usually brings to mind a growing backlog of unsold houses. That is not what the area's listing count shows. On September 30, 2026, the South Haven, Bangor and Covert area had 147 active residential listings, compared with 144 at the end of September 2025.
The homes that did sell were not sitting longer, either. Average days on market for the area in September 2026 was 47, down from 58 a year earlier, and the year-to-date average was 50 days against 51.
Inventory still built over the course of 2026. Active listings rose from 76 in January to a peak of 152 at the end of August before easing to 147 in September. At September's pace of 37 sales, 147 listings works out to roughly four months of supply. That gives a buyer more choice than in the tight years. It is a normal fall build, not a glut.
Middle-of-the-market homes in the area are selling at steady prices and on normal timelines. Fewer buyers are closing at the top. A second-home buyer shopping lakefront or near-lake property this fall is not looking at a backlog of homes that failed to sell. They are looking at a smaller pool of competing buyers in the price range where most lake-oriented homes sit.
What happened to listings last winter
The seasonal pattern is where a buyer's timing comes in. Here is how the same reporting area moved from October 2025 through February 2026.
| Month | Active residential listings at month-end | Sales closed | Average days on market |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 2025 | 144 | 40 | 43 |
| November 2025 | 128 | 32 | 57 |
| December 2025 | 83 | 27 | 61 |
| January 2026 | 76 | 18 | 82 |
| February 2026 | 80 | 21 | 47 |
Between the end of November and the end of December 2025, active listings fell from 128 to 83. Only 27 homes closed in December, so most of that drop was not sales. The year before followed the same shape, with 133 listings at the end of October 2024, 129 in November and 101 in December. The monthly reports do not say why each listing came off the market. The timing, though, matches when lake-area owners close up for the season.
The January row matters too. Only 18 sales closed in January 2026, and those homes averaged 82 days on market. The houses that sell in the dead of winter are largely the ones that were listed in the fall and stayed on the market. By February, average days on market had fallen back to 47.
Why late November is the window
If 2026 follows the last two years, the largest set of unsold summer and fall listings will still be on the market through late November and into early December, before the year-end drop. That has three practical effects for a buyer.
Selection comes first. A buyer who waits for January will probably choose from about half as many listings as a buyer who shops now, based on how far the count fell between November and January last winter. With fewer high-end closings this year, the remaining pool also faces fewer competing buyers at the top.
An owner who has carried a listing from summer through November has watched 2026's thinner high-end market firsthand. That seller is deciding whether to stay listed through winter or pull the home and try again in spring. A serious offer in late November reaches them at the point they are making that call.
Weather is the last factor. A November or early December showing lets a buyer see how a lake house handles cold weather, wind off the water and shorter days before the snow arrives. Our guide to four-season living at a South Haven Lake Michigan retreat covers what that looks like once you own the home.
The data does not show buyers getting discounts. SWMAR's monthly reports do not include sale-to-list ratios or price reductions, and the area median has stayed in a narrow band all year. What the data does show is fewer competing buyers at the top and more homes to choose from now than there will be in January.
Where condos and in-town homes fit
South Haven's own zip code has a separate SWMAR snapshot, though it is older. For April 2026, the 49090 report showed 10 single-family sales at a $532,500 median and 4 condo sales at a $375,000 median. Those figures are from spring and come from small samples, but they show that in-town South Haven prices sit well above the combined area median. A $365,000 area median is not what a buyer should expect to pay inside the city.
A few questions buyers ask
Will the October numbers change this picture? SWMAR posts each month's report on its market statistics page. September 2026 is the latest month used here. If the October report shows the year-to-date gap between the average and the median closing, the high-end market is recovering. If the gap stays wide, the pattern described above still holds.
Does a smaller January market mean better prices in January? Not on this evidence. January 2026 had the fewest sales of the winter and the longest average days on market, and the median shows no seasonal discount. What a January buyer loses is selection.
I'm buying from out of state. Can I act on a late-fall listing without visiting several times? Many second-home buyers do. Our guide for remote buyers securing a South Haven second home covers how that process works, and the buyers page explains how showings and offers are handled.
If you are weighing a South Haven purchase this winter, the next few weeks are when the most fall listings are still on the market. Amy O'Sullivan can go through the active South Haven listings with you and compare them with what sold nearby this year. If you own a lake home and are deciding whether to stay listed through winter, get your home valuation based on this fall's numbers.